What the data shows
These are real examples from the agencies ranked on this site, checked in August 2026.
| Agency | Type | Position |
|---|---|---|
| Martin & Co Aberdeen | National franchise, locally owned since 2005 | First in Aberdeen, 4.9 from 1,365 |
| Clan Gordon, Edinburgh | Independent | First in Edinburgh, 4.9 on two platforms |
| We Let Properties, Manchester | Independent, lettings only | First in Manchester, 4.9 from 1,689 |
| Slater Hogg & Howison | National, part of Connells | Tenth in Glasgow, despite the largest branch in the city |
| Clyde Property | Regional, eleven branches | Ninth in Glasgow, 4.3 at branch against 1.8 group wide |
| DJ Alexander | National, Lomond group | Fifth in Glasgow, fifth in Aberdeen, ninth in Edinburgh |
The pattern is that the same brand lands in different places in different cities, which is the clearest possible sign that the brand is not what is being measured.
The category nobody talks about
Most of the interesting agencies are neither purely local nor purely national.
Martin and Co Aberdeen carries a national brand, but the franchisee, Vector Properties, has been Aberdeen owned since 2005 and has more than twenty years of local trading behind it. Northwood Aberdeen is locally managed but the company is registered in York. Belvoir Aberdeen operates under a registration held by the corporate entity in Grantham rather than by a local franchisee.
Calling any of those simply a chain or simply an independent would be inaccurate. Ask who actually owns the branch and how long they have run it.
What a chain genuinely buys you
- Out of hours cover and cover for holidays and illness, which a two person office cannot always provide.
- Legal and compliance resource behind the branch, which matters as rules change.
- Coverage across cities, useful if your portfolio is spread. DJ Alexander manages more than ten thousand properties across Scotland.
- Products an independent rarely offers, such as Northwood's guaranteed rent.
What an independent genuinely buys you
- A named contact who knows the property, rather than whoever answers.
- Specialism. Cairn has run West End student and HMO property in Glasgow since 2000, and that depth is hard for a general branch to match.
- Local market judgement on rent levels, street by street.
- Fee transparency, which independents are somewhat more likely to offer, although the difference is smaller than you would expect.
Judge the branch, not the brand
- Find the review score for the specific office, not the company. Group and branch figures differ by more than two points in several cases we found.
- Ask how many properties the person managing yours looks after.
- Ask how long the branch has been under its current ownership. A franchise that changed hands last year is a new business with an old name.
- Check the registration or redress details against the entity that actually holds them, which may be in another country.
- Ask for last year's average void period and arrears rate. Firms that measure themselves answer immediately.
Our city pages do this branch by branch, and state where every figure came from.
Common questions
Are national letting agents more expensive?
Not consistently. Published tariffs from national brands in our data range from twelve percent including VAT to fifteen point six percent, and independents range from ten point eight percent to fourteen point four percent. The ranges overlap almost completely.
Do independents give better service?
Sometimes, and the evidence does not support it as a rule. The highest scoring agency in Edinburgh is an independent, the highest in Aberdeen is a national franchise, and the highest in Manchester is a lettings only independent. What they share is a strong branch, not a business model.
What about franchises specifically?
A franchise is usually local ownership under national systems, which can be the best of both. It also means quality varies branch to branch far more than the brand suggests, so check the specific office rather than the name above the door.
Keep reading